BetterChessGamesOpeningsRatingsDailyPricing★ Add to ClaudeLog inGet started
HomeOpening trapsMagnus Smith Trap

Magnus Smith Trap

Sicilian Defense, Sozin Variation (1.e4 c5) · B57 · You play White · Wins the queen

Part of the Sicilian Defense: see the full opening guide

Starting position
Engine ready — step through to see live evals.
Press ▶ Watch to play the line out, or Next to step through it — the engine evaluates every position.
You play White · play the main line move for move.

The Magnus Smith Trap is named after Magnus Smith, the three-time Canadian champion of the early 1900s, and lives in the Sozin Sicilian, the setup Bobby Fischer later made his trademark. Black plays one casual fianchetto move, ...g6, at exactly the wrong moment, and White's light-squared bishop and queen combine in a two-move deflection that wins the queen. Fischer himself annotated the refutation in My 60 Memorable Games.

The idea in one line

In the Sozin after 5...Nc6 6.Bc4, Black plays 6...g6?!, ignoring the bishop on the a2-g8 diagonal. White trades on c6 and strikes with 8.e5!. The natural 8...dxe5?? opens the d-file, and 9.Bxf7+! deflects the king (it is the only legal move) so that 10.Qxd8 wins the queen for a bishop.

How the trap works

After 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 d6 3.d4 cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6 5.Nc3 Nc6 6.Bc4, White's bishop points at f7 and the game has become the Fischer-Sozin Attack. The thematic reply is 6...e6, blunting the bishop. Instead 6...g6?! invites the combination: 7.Nxc6 bxc6 8.e5! attacks the f6 knight, and the pawn cannot be ignored. Everything now hangs together tactically: 8...dxe5?? opens the d-file, and Black's queen on d8 is defended only by the king. So 9.Bxf7+! deflects: the king must take (9...Kxf7 is literally the only legal move, since d7 is covered by the queen down the open file and e7 is blocked by Black's own pawn), and 10.Qxd8 scoops the queen. Nothing recaptures on d8: the f8 bishop blocks the h8 rook, and the f6 knight does not reach d8. White has won queen for bishop.

The move that springs it

8… dxe5 — 8...dxe5?? (ply 16) is the losing move, opening the d-file with the queen still on it. Fischer's verdict was blunt: correct is 8...Ng4, keeping the damage to a bad structure. The earlier 6...g6?! is what invited everything: it did nothing about the c4 bishop's stare at f7, and that bishop is the engine of the deflection.

How to avoid it

As Black in the Sozin, remember the granite rule: meet 6.Bc4 with 6...e6, so the bishop bites on granite and Bxf7 tricks disappear. If you have played 6...g6 and White uncorks 8.e5, do not open the d-file: play Fischer's 8...Ng4 and grovel a little (Lasker defended 8...Ng4 9.e6 f5 against Schlechter in their 1910 world championship match and held). The pattern to burn in: open d-file plus bishop on c4 equals Bxf7+ followed by Qxd8.

The full line, explained

6. Bc4Bc4: the Sozin bishop takes aim at f7. Its whole career is about that one square.
6… g6...g6?! walks toward the trap. 6...e6 blunts the bishop and is the main line for good reason.
7. Nxc6Nxc6 removes the knight that could block the d-file with ...Nd4 tricks and doubles Black's pawns.
8. e5e5! the pawn breaks in: the f6 knight is attacked and the d-file is one capture from opening.
8… dxe5...dxe5?? opens the d-file. Fischer: correct is 8...Ng4, when White is only clearly better.
9. Bxf7+Bxf7+! deflection. The king must take: d7 is covered by White's queen and e7 is Black's own pawn.
9… Kxf7...Kxf7, the only legal move, and the queen on d8 now stands undefended.
10. Qxd8Qxd8: queen for bishop. The f8 bishop even blocks the h8 rook from recapturing.

Frequently asked

Is the trap named after Magnus Carlsen?

No. Magnus Smith (1869-1934) was a three-time Canadian champion, and the Sozin Sicilian even carries a Magnus Smith Variation in the opening books. Chess historian Edward Winter argues the trap's name is a misnomer historically, but the label has stuck for over a century.

What should Black play after 8.e5 instead of taking?

Fischer gives 8...Ng4 as correct, and Lasker showed the defensive method with 8...Ng4 9.e6 f5 against Schlechter in their 1910 world championship match, eventually holding a draw. Black stands worse but fights on. 8...Nh5? fails too: Fischer analyzes 9.Qf3!, when g4 and Ne4 follow and Black's queen ends up trapped.

More traps to learn

Siberian Trap
Smith-Morra Gambit (1.e4 c5 2.d4) · Checkmate
Learn & play ›
Fried Liver Attack
Two Knights Defense · Winning attack (knight sacrifice)
Learn & play ›
Every trap works until your opponent does not play into it — and then the same move often loses a piece. That is exactly what BetterChess catches: it checks the position instead of recognising the pattern.
See it catch the move that looks right →All traps

A trap only works if your opponent makes the mistake — strong players sidestep these, which is why each page also shows how to avoid it. Every line here is checked legal with the same engine the board runs, and every checkmate is verified.

BetterChess

A chess engine for Claude. It reads your actual position and explains the why behind every move — grounded, never guessed.

Earn 30% Commission
Featured on SpellingJoy

Product

FeaturesSee it workPricingFree game reviewBest move calculatorChess game reviewsChess openingsChess opening trapsChess glossaryWhat's a good chess rating?Daily chess puzzleFamous chess playersAffiliate programFor chess clubsHow to use it in ClaudeBetterChess for Claude

Compare

AI chess coachBest AI chess coachesFree instant game reviewvs DecodeChessvs Aimchessvs Chessablevs a private coach

Players & records

Best players of all timeBest players in the worldBest female playersYoungest grandmastersChess records

Company

AboutFAQContact

Legal

PrivacyTermsRefunds
BetterChess is a practice tool. We make no guarantee that you'll reach 1800 or any rating. Improvement depends on your own practice, effort, and skill.
BetterChess is a connector for Claude. Claude and Anthropic are trademarks of Anthropic PBC. BetterChess is an independent product and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Anthropic.
Engine analysis powered by Stockfish, © the Stockfish developers, licensed under the GPL v3 (source).
© 2026 BetterChessbetterchess.co